The pay stub says $2,900 a month, the rent is $1,275, and now you have to decide. It's an easy call, and a fair one, if you wrote the rule before the first application came in. So pick your criteria, keep only the parts of the form that answer them, and give every applicant the same form to sign.
Write your criteria first
Here are three to start with, and the part of the form that answers each:
- Income of at least three times the rent. For a $1,275 rent, that's $3,825 a month, so $2,900 is a no. "Work and income" asks for it, and the pay stubs and a call to the employer confirm it.
- Two years of rent paid on time. "Where they've lived" lists the last two landlords. Call them, or ask for a landlord reference letter.
- A credit and background check that meets a standard you write down now. The screening box adds the applicant's signed permission to run it.
If a section doesn't help you apply a criterion or a lease rule, switch it off.
Questions to leave off the form
Start with disability. You can ask every applicant whether they can meet the terms of the lease, like paying the rent and following the house rules. You can't ask whether they, or anyone who'll live with them, has a disability, or how severe it is. That's 24 CFR 100.202(c).
The Fair Housing Act also bars any rental notice or statement that shows a preference based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, family status or national origin. So keep the questions on the tenancy:
If the report plays any part in a no
When a screening report helps you turn someone down, or ask for a bigger deposit, or require a co-signer, you owe the applicant an adverse action notice. That holds even if the report played only a small part and income was another reason.
It has to say three things, and the last one gives the applicant 60 days to ask for a free copy of the report. This is general information, not legal advice.
Check your state before you set the fee
A state can limit what you charge. In New York, section 238-a of the Real Property Law caps the fee for background and credit checks at what the checks cost you or $20, whichever is less. You can't charge it when the applicant brings a background or credit check from the past 30 days, and you can only collect it after you give them a copy of the check and the receipt from the company that ran it.