The landlord who reads your reference letter already has the tenant's application. They check your dates and rent against it, then look for what's missing. A letter that never says the rent came on time, or that the deposit came back in full, looks like a no, and they'll call to ask why. So decide which letter you can sign before you tick anything.
What the next landlord looks for
Before you tick a line, find the record behind it. If the next landlord calls, that's what you'll be reading from.
| Line in the letter | Left out, it says | Check this first |
|---|---|---|
| Paid rent on time every month | Rent was late, at least some months | Your rent ledger |
| Followed the lease | There was a lease problem, like an unapproved pet or extra occupant | The lease and any violation notices you sent |
| Kept the home clean and in good condition | There was damage or a cleaning bill | The move-in and move-out inspections |
| Gave proper notice before moving out | They left early or without notice | Their written notice to move out |
| Got the full security deposit back | You kept part of the deposit | Your deposit statement |
| I would rent to them again | You wouldn't | Your own call: the one line no record backs |
If something went wrong and you want to say so, put it in "Anything to add" as a dated fact: "Rent was late in March and June 2025, and paid in full both times." A word like "unreliable" tells the next landlord less, and it's harder to stand behind.
Pick the letter you can sign
A full reference. For the tenant whose ledger, inspections and deposit statement are all clean. Tick every box and sign it.
Dates and rent only. Untick everything, and the letter confirms who rented the home, when, and for how much. It suits a tenancy with problems you'd rather not write up, or a policy of confirming facts only. If it's your policy for every tenant, say so in "Anything to add", or the next landlord will assume it's about this one: "We confirm dates and rent only, for every former tenant."
Or decline. A short reply is enough. Say you can confirm the dates and rent by phone, and when the next landlord calls, answer only that.
Asking your landlord for a reference letter
If you're the tenant, you can do most of the work for your landlord. Fill in the dates, address and rent from your lease, put your landlord's name and contact details under "From", and tick only the lines you know they can confirm. Leave "I would rent to them again" for them to decide. Then copy the text and send it, with the new landlord's name and the date your application is due, so they can edit it, sign it and send it on.
Ask when you give notice. A letter written before you leave won't mention notice or the deposit, and that's normal: nobody expects those lines while you still live there.
Keep it to the tenancy
A reference letter goes with a rental application, so keep it to rent, the lease, the home and the deposit. The federal Fair Housing Act bars any statement "with respect to the sale or rental of a dwelling" that shows a preference, limitation or discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, family status or national origin. So leave out anything about the tenant's children, faith, background or health. This is general information, not legal advice.